Is It Wrong to Want More Than Basic Maternity Care as a Christian Woman?
“God will provide”… but only up to a point?
“God will provide.”
It’s something we say a lot as Christians. And rightly so. We believe in a God who knows what we need, who cares about the details of our lives and who can be trusted with them.
But I wonder whether sometimes we say “God will provide” while subtly putting parameters around what we think that provision is allowed to look like.
I’ve heard variations of this particularly when it comes to maternity care.
“Be grateful for what you’ve got.”
“That’s what the NHS is for.”
Before I go any further, this is not an NHS-bashing post. I spent years working in the NHS. There are incredible professionals within it doing deeply valuable work every single day, often within circumstances that make providing the standard of care they would like to provide incredibly difficult.
But there is something I have noticed, particularly within Christian spaces, about the way we talk about wanting more than the standard provision.
Somewhere along the way, “God will provide” can start to sound a little bit like “God will provide the basics, and you should be grateful for them.”
And I don't think those are actually the same thing.
What counts as a need?
As Christian women, we often speak about trusting God to provide for our needs and we quote the Bible when we do so:
“And my God will meet all your needs according to the riches of his glory in Christ Jesus.”— Philippians 4:19
But I think sometimes we are very quick to decide for ourselves (and sometimes others) what counts as a legitimate “need”.
Clinical safety? Of course.
A healthy baby? Absolutely.
Access to maternity care? Yes.
But what about feeling emotionally safe as well as physically safe? What about knowing the person who is caring for you? What about not having to explain your history, your fears and your preferences over and over again to different people? What about having somebody alongside you who knows what matters to you before you even walk into the room?
We have somehow come to regard these things as extras. Lovely if you can have them, perhaps, but certainly not something you should expect.
The problem is that continuity, relationship, trust and emotional safety aren't simply luxurious additions to maternity care. They are part of what the safest maternity care looks like.
And we have evidence to support that.
Continuity of midwifery care isn't simply about having a nicer experience. We know that it is associated with meaningful differences in outcomes and experiences for women and babies.
So why are we so quick to categorise it as “more than you need”?
I speak to women who, on paper, are receiving perfectly adequate maternity care.
They have appointments. They have access to screening. Someone checks their blood pressure and listens to their baby's heartbeat. There is a hospital they can attend when they go into labour.
Nothing is necessarily “wrong”.
And yet they don't feel safe.
They feel anxious before appointments. They worry about who they are going to see. They don't know whether the person in front of them will understand the decisions they have already made. They find themselves repeatedly explaining the same history. Sometimes they don't know who to ask when something is worrying them.
That matters.
Feeling safe during pregnancy and birth is not simply about whether somebody is available to intervene if something goes wrong. Birth is an intensely vulnerable experience. The environment you are in, the people around you and whether you feel safe with them can affect how you labour, how you communicate, how you make decisions and how you experience what happens to you.
That doesn't mean everybody needs an independent midwife. Of course it doesn't.
But it does mean we need to stop pretending that relational care is somehow frivolous.
But shouldn't I just be grateful?
I think this is where it becomes particularly complicated for Christian women.
Gratitude is important to us. We should be grateful. And compared with women in many parts of the world, we have extraordinary access to maternity care in this country.
But gratitude and discernment are not opposites.
Being grateful for something doesn't mean we cannot also recognise its limitations. I can be profoundly grateful that the NHS exists, grateful for the care that it provides, and grateful for the people working incredibly hard within it, while also acknowledging that the way maternity services are currently structured may not provide the kind of care a particular woman needs.
Those things can all be true at the same time.
And recognising that you would benefit from something different does not automatically make you entitled, demanding or ungrateful.
I wonder whether, as Christians, we sometimes find it difficult to hold those two things together. We can become so concerned with being grateful for what we have that we feel uncomfortable even acknowledging that we might need something else.
But Jesus tells us:
“I have come that they may have life, and have it to the full.”John 10:10
I'm not suggesting that “life to the full” means God promises us every comfort we might want. Clearly it doesn't. But neither do I think gratitude requires us to ignore our needs or feel guilty for recognising them.
We can be genuinely thankful for what we have and still ask, honestly and prayerfully, whether something different would better support us in this particular season.
What if God's provision looks different from what you expected?
And perhaps this is where “God will provide” comes back in. Because once we have recognised that we need something, I wonder whether we sometimes decide in advance what God's answer is allowed to look like.
We are comfortable recognising God's provision when it meets a basic need. But when His provision appears to go beyond what we consider strictly necessary, we can become strangely hesitant about receiving it.
If somebody tells us that they prayed because they didn't know how they were going to pay their electricity bill, and then an unexpected payment arrived at exactly the right time, we might happily call that God's provision.
But what if somebody has spent months praying about their birth, knows that they are deeply anxious about fragmented maternity care, and then unexpectedly finds themselves in a financial position where they could afford continuity of care?
Wouldn't that be provision too?
I'm not saying that if you pray hard enough, God will give you the money for private maternity care. I really want to be clear about that. Christianity is not a prosperity gospel, and God's faithfulness cannot be measured by what appears in our bank accounts.
But perhaps we shouldn't limit God's provision in the opposite direction either.
Ephesians 3:20 speaks of God as:
“…him who is able to do immeasurably more than all we ask or imagine…”
That verse isn't a promise that God will give us everything we want. But it does remind us something important about the character of the God we are trusting. He is not constrained by our ideas about what is reasonable, necessary or “enough”.
His provision might be financial. It might be somebody offering practical help or a listening ear. It might be finding the right midwife within the NHS, meeting a doula who immediately makes you feel safe, having family step in to support you, or discovering an option you didn't even know existed.
The point isn't that God's provision will always look abundant in a material sense. It's that perhaps we shouldn't decide beforehand what it is allowed to look like.
So instead of asking, “Is this more than I really need?”, perhaps there is a different question:
“God, is this something you are providing for me?”
This isn’t really about private care.
Obviously, I provide private maternity care. It would be disingenuous to write this without acknowledging that.
But I don't believe every woman needs an independent midwife. I don't believe paying privately automatically gives you a better birth. And I certainly don't believe that women who cannot afford private care somehow have less access to God's provision.
This is about something bigger than that.
It is about giving ourselves permission to actually consider what we need rather than immediately dismissing anything beyond the standard offering as excessive.
For one woman, that might mean employing an independent midwife. For another, it might mean paying for a doula. It might mean choosing a particular antenatal course, having counselling before birth, travelling further for care, asking somebody from church to support you practically, or simply having the confidence to ask for something different within NHS care.
“If any of you lacks wisdom, you should ask God… and it will be given to you.”— James 1:5
Perhaps that is where we start.
Not with “What am I allowed to ask for?” Not even with “What does everybody else think I should need?” But with prayer, wisdom and an honest assessment of what would help you to feel safe, informed and supported as you prepare to give birth.
You can be grateful for what is available and still recognise that you need something different.
You can value the NHS and choose to supplement it.
You can trust God to provide without deciding beforehand exactly what His provision is supposed to look like.
And sometimes, receiving something good doesn't require us to justify why we deserve it.
Sometimes we are simply allowed to receive it.
References and Further Reading
Fernandez Turienzo et al. (2026). The Impact of Community-Based Midwife Continuity of Care Models for Women Living in Areas of Social Disadvantage and Ethnic Diversity in the United Kingdom: A Prospective Cohort Study
Sandall et al. (2024). Midwife continuity of care models versus other models of care for childbearing women
Comments